What Would You Do?
By Keith Boykin, in race
Wednesday, November 28 2007, 12:25PM
What would you do in this situation?
One day a black teenager goes to a party where alcohol is served and a white teenage girl asks him to leave because she feels "uncomfortable" around him. He complies and goes home, but the girl then tells a male teenager at the party that the black teen had threatened her once before in an Internet chat room. The white teen then calls the black teen on his cell phone and yells at him using the N-word. Unsatisfied, the white teen then gathers four other white teenagers and they drive to the black teen's house.
The drunk white teenagers pull up in the driveway of the house and block off the street. One of the teens is carrying an aluminum baseball bat. The black teen and his father then walk outside the house to the driveway. The father is carrying an unlicensed handgun. The black teen follows with a hunting shotgun. Words and threats are exchanged and eventually the father fires one shot into the face of the first white teenager. The white teen dies at a hospital an hour later.
Those are the apparently undisputed facts of the case involving the tragic death of 17-year-old Daniel Cicciaro Jr. last August in Long Island, New York. The black father, John White, was initially charged with murder, but prosecutors later reduced the charge to manslaughter.
Yesterday in court, White's lawyer argued that the boys in the driveway were acting like "a lynch mob" and invoked the history of racial tensions in America to establish his state of mind at the time. The defendant claims the shooting was accidental.
But prosecutors responded that the case was not about racism, underage drinking, or the victim's actions. Prosecutors acknowledge that Cicciaro and his friends went to the house expecting an argument or a fight but they got more than they bargained for. "Just like Daniel and his friends didn't get what they expected, John White did not act as you would expect a 53-year-old man to act," the lead prosecutor said in court.
Prosecutors argued that the elder Mr. White should have locked the doors and called the police instead of confronting the teenagers in his driveway. But White's lawyer argues that he told his wife to call the police before he went outside to stop the teens. White maintains the gun accidentally discharged when Cicciaro reached for it.
That part of the story is a "he-said/he-said" dispute, and the jury will have to decide whom to believe. But a few conclusions can be drawn from the facts that both sides agree about.
First, although you do have the legal right to defend yourself and your family from danger, you do not have the right to use lethal force against someone who is not an immediate threat to your safety or the safety of others. In this case, White never claims he acted in self-defense; he maintains it was an accident, which means he did not intend to shoot the victim.
Second, in a perfect world White should have tried to diffuse the situation as an adult among angry teenagers, just as the prosecutors argued. But this is not a perfect world. If it were a perfect world, then five white teenagers wouldn't have pulled up on a black man's driveway with a baseball bat.
In the real world, black men like James Byrd get beaten to death with baseball bats by groups of angry white men. In the real world, black teenagers like Emmet Till are murdered just for whistling at white girls. In the real world, young black men like Michael Griffith and Michael Sandy are chased and killed by white kids in Howard Beach. All that happened in John White's life.
John White says he is the grandson of an Alabama man whose two brothers were lynched in the 1940s. He said the .32-caliber revolver he used in the killing was bequeathed to him by his grandfather for protection. That could explain his state of mind, but the jury will have to decide if he acted wrongly or not.
Maybe Mr. White never should have opened the door that August night in 2006. And maybe he was careless by bringing out a gun to fight against a mob with a baseball bat. And maybe he should have waited for the police to come instead of trying to defend himself in his driveway. All that may be true. And maybe he's guilty of bad judgment. But unless prosecutors can prove that he pulled the trigger on purpose, I'm still not convinced he's guilty of a crime.

Comments conceal
Derrick from Philly
November 28 2007, 12:41PM
They came to his home to do violence. Americans believe you have the right to own guns to protect yourself, don't they? And if the white teens were calling folks "niggers" on the phone, what makes anyone think they didn't use that word when they blocked Mr White's driveway? The incident was racially motivated.
On another blog that I visit regularly(guess which one), some there would say what if it were the other way around? What if 5 black teens went to a white man's home with baseball bats. Well, then, you'd have 5 black teens (not one) shot 300 times by the homeowner, neighbors, and the police. The wife would've fired a few shots too.
The NRA should be helping to pay Mr. White's defense attorneys' fees.
Billy
November 28 2007, 1:15PM
Wow-I probably shouldn't be surprised about these incidents but it never ceases to amaze me at the world we live in.
Alto
November 28 2007, 1:20PM
Wow...America is still a very depressing place. Yet and still seeing a documentary regarding African Law and Customs lat night it really seems as if even over there the law and justice dispensed thereof is skewed..Idont know..The saying goes when you come to start shit dont be surprised when you get shitted. They were racially motivated ALL the way..and what was the teen doing to manhdnle the gun away from the father ?..He most likely wouldve used that very gun on that family so I feel the guy was warranted..But one other thing..For Mr.White to live in a suburb and whatnot why didn he take the time out to purchase himself a registered gun ? Shit even thewife could've gotten a registered gun if he didnt feel safe about it.
thirtydaes
November 28 2007, 1:24PM
Ok, I've had enough of this nonsense. Keith you wouldn't have even written about this story had the other teenagers who'd confronted Mr. White's sons had been black, which happens all to frequently. I am just weary of the outcries when black men are victims of crimes perpetrated by whites but everyone is silent about the overwhelming majority of black men who are victimized by other black men. Additionally, Keith, the Michael Sandy incident you referenced had nothing to do with him being targeted because he was black and you know this. Come on Keith, you are far too intelligent to post misleading articles like this. I'm waiting for you to wax philosophical about Sean Taylor's murder and how our culture contributed to it and this is what you give us instead?? Truth is, black men have much, much more to fear in each other than they do in angry bigoted white men.
Colby Snyder
November 28 2007, 1:35PM
This article hit home for me because I have been in a similiar situation and sometimes I wish I had handled it differently. When angry people, intoxicated with liquid courage, show up at your home with weapons you have no idea what to expect. He probably could have handled the situation better but under pressure like that your mind is going in all kinds of places and the natural thing to do is protect yourself and family. I feel an abundance of sympathy for the family of Daniel Ciccario and with our judicial system I feel the same sympathy for the White family.
Reginald
November 28 2007, 1:45PM
I would have done exactly what Mr. White did!!
Callingthe police and even waiting for the police would be only a band-aid on the problem. If they wanted to beat up Mr. White's son, they would do it another day or when he was at school and that would be a four on one fight. It was necessary to confront them in the moment, when their tempers were raised. The only way to deal with a bully is to face him and make him or her feel your conviction not to be victimized by them for one second. If I had a mob trying to hurt me or "Lynch me," I would want my father, mother, friends, neighbor, etc help me end the madness right then and there. If the racial situation would have been reversed, as in the Jena Six case, there wouldn't even be a court case.
Blue
November 28 2007, 1:46PM
Moral of the story: Don't roll up in front of somebody's spot five-deep with a bat thinking ain't shit gonna happen to you. When you play big and bad and look for a fight you better be prepared for what might come your way. I'm not saying the child deserved to die, but I bet his friends will think twice before they try that shit again.
Bryan Jones
November 28 2007, 2:05PM
As mush as I complain about living in the mid-west, that is one thing they have correct down here in Texas. With the "Stand Your Ground Law" ,pasted last year, the right to defend you and your property, to include deadly force, extends to your property line and your car. A baseball bat can be a deadly weapon. And it's unreasonable to have to wait until being swung upon. Proximity is relevant when considering immediate threat.
'dre
November 28 2007, 2:21PM
Well, I assume that it was Italians who spewed the n-word, and, thought they were in the wild west of a posse and after the black kid. I have little to no sympathy for the kid who dies. Call me callous, but, I for one and sick and tired of these two bit wanna be racist hoods who think they can pick and chose how black folks can live in this country.
Lock the doors and call the police? In New York? Please, with a mob outside your crib? Not advocating violence, but, when you are threatened on YOUR property, you have a right to defend it.
Ron Lee
November 28 2007, 2:27PM
Black parents need to really consider who their son or duaghter will be dating before they move in some of these neighborhoods. I feel sorry for Mr.White,but even sorrier for his son no telling what abuse he has endured. There are beautiful Black suburban & urban neighborhoods all over. And Black parents need to learn to shop around. PEACE.
Shabaka
November 28 2007, 2:34PM
I don't know about gun regulations in the States-and I actually don't think that's relevant-but ownership of a deadly weapon should make one think before action-especially a 53 year old. Centuries of blatant racism in America played a major role in all of this despite what prosecutors are claiming...but in my opinion he's guilty of killing someone and should be sentenced accordingly.
J
November 28 2007, 2:42PM
It's a shame that boy has a wad for a father. He's got like a million strikes against him. I can only imagine what his mother's like if she would lay down with such a sack.
White had no business walking out of that house. He walked out to put bullets in the guidos. There was no "heat of the moment" anger. He wasn't cornered. They didn't come into his house. Those little skinny orange bastards were standing outside holding bats. Effin. BATS. They weren't about to do anything but attack his mailbox. Their roid rage wasn't anywhere near the "pull a 12 on him" level.
The more we try to paint people like this as victims of a racist justice system the more this will happen. This BS has to stop.
Dean Green
November 28 2007, 2:47PM
As an African American with a sense or history regarding Emmitt Till, James Byrd and others, I'm well aware of the lynch mob mentality. Still, I believe that Mr. White and his son should have stayed in his home and called the police. Now, a young man is dead and Mr. White may go to jail. There are more than enough tears to go around.
MidwestGuy
November 28 2007, 2:58PM
Thirtydaes>Give it a rest
America stood still when Michael Vick was found to have fought and killed an animal--an animal. It became an indictment on hip-hop--the black community.
Imus called black women nappy headed-ho's. It became an indictment on the black community.
Sean Taylor's death has now turned into a study on the black community.
Now you want to take this case and also turn it into a black community problem.
Believe me, as you have proven here, there is ample focus on the black community's problem. Many times people tend focus on the "black community's" problem even when it's not warranted -- Vick, Taylor and now White.
Bingo
November 28 2007, 3:15PM
This is exactly why I was so glad to hear that Keith Boykin is shutting this website down at the end of the year.
Not even a day goes by that he breaks his promise to provide positive stories and resorts to this tabloid race-card nonsense.
Great job, Keith - you glossed over The Secret pretty quickly, because apparently you are right back to your petty, negative, divisive ways.
Hopefully in your next venture of reinventing yourself you will realize that you don't live in a vacuum, and that working to build a better world can't include your preoccupation with drivel like this.
WTF?
MidwestGuy
November 28 2007, 3:39PM
Bingo, glad to know that as of today, your most recent post will be your last.
That is unless you are going to continue posting to a website of a person whose views you are obviously opposed to.
Now that wouldn't make sense would it?
WTF?
LaRufus
November 28 2007, 3:54PM
Midwest, keep it real boo, these trolls are too much. The way they dismiss racism is akin to Trent Lott saying the civil war was wrong.
Bingo
November 28 2007, 3:57PM
Hey MidwestGuy - you sure do take delight in shooting down anyone who doesn't share YOUR opinion, don't you. Last I heard Boykin was an adult, and he doesn't post any restrictions that only lapdogs who goosestep to him can post on his site.
Too bad you weren't around when his website first started up and he wasn't petty - resorting to tactics like this.
But of course, you in your supreme loyalty obviously know better than anyone who might disagree with your kow-towing.
Derrick from Philly
November 28 2007, 4:04PM
This news story is totally appropriate for this blog. THis is not just a blog geared towards the concerns of Gay people, it's a blog geared towards the concerns of Black people.
Would Keith have written the story had the attackers been Black? Maybe not. Black on black is not news. But he would have written on it had Mr White or his son been Gay, and been attacked by a gay-bashing mob (White or Black). As Gays, most visitors to this blog would have wanted to know about such an incident. And as Blacks, most of us are very interested in the actual story presented here.
What made those thugs think they could get away with attacking the home of a grown man--a father with his famly in danger?
As I said, had the boys been Black, and the father White, all 5 would be dead, and most of the country would have agreed with a white Mr White. I'm not sure Black boys would've been crazy enough to attack some White man's family...well, nowadays, who knows?
Ostend Street
November 28 2007, 4:31PM
You show up on a man's property in a threatening manner, with a group of threatening people, full of liquor and expect rational behavior. Well, unfortunately, all that bottled up hate and rage came to a tragic end. If you're looking for a problem, you usually don't disappoint yourself.
Jeff Hobbs
November 28 2007, 4:31PM
I want a chat room transcript. what made this girl so afraid? They're teenagers. Telling someone they're not interested and maybe calling them a bitch for being racist is a threat? I'm speculating but I know if four people of any race came to my house with any threatening body language I'd have ran and called the police. Then again i don't own a gun. Who knows how i'd react if in a situation like this. Probably pee my pants!:(
Terrence
November 28 2007, 5:17PM
Keith, ironically a similar *situation happened in suburban St. Louis* - either most or all of the parties involved were black. A high schooler was followed home by a mob after a fight took place. The mob was encouraging the two boys to continue fighting. The boy went into the home. The mob started banging on the windows of the house and yelled for the boy to come out. The boy and his mother came out with guns.
Members of the mob kept antagonizing the mother and the boy (ON THEIR FRONT LAWN) and both of them chased the mob - busting caps at them all in the suburbs. Unfortunately, one kid was killed. The mother was around the same age of Mr. White. Police arrested her and her son citing that the mother should have stayed in the home and allowed the police to address the matter.
I disagree. Once intruders - who intend to do bodily or physical harm - step on your property - blast them into oblivion. Sorry but that is how I feel.
Check out the attached link in red.
LaFontaye
November 28 2007, 7:03PM
As far as I'm concerned, Mr. White stopped 4 dead punk ass Neo Klansmen too shy.
The fuck y'all talking 'bout?? - I'm supposed to hide and cower from a damn lynch mob who've encroached upon my property at night to threaten me and/or mine??! The hell outta here with that tripe! YT got what he damn well deserved.
Louis
November 28 2007, 7:20PM
Why is there a debate on this subject? If the four teenagers would have been Black, they would have arrested the other three for assault and attempted murder. Yes, the police would have ruled the bat was a weapon. Let four black men run up on the police with bats and see what happens. All would be dead. The father should have just stated he was in fear of his life and that of his son. Bottom line, these kids were aggressive and carried an arm weapon and intended to do damage. And, let's not write off a bat as some light weapon. Unless it was a plastic bat, a regular bat can kill and do so serious damage. I am glad the father handled his buisness. It shows a lack of respect when you come on another person's property to start a fight.
MidwestGuy
November 28 2007, 8:25PM
Bingo, reread my post to you.
There is nothing that I agreed with Keith on.
There is no "opinion" to be disputed.
I said that it makes no sense for you to post onto a message board of someone whose views you are opposed to.
Do you post onto anti-gay or anti-black websites?
More than likely not.
Why?
Because the views are probably so beyond what you can reasonably agree with.
Same thing here.
If you can explain why you would post HERE, then I will defer.
Otherwise,
A hit dog will bark.
A hit dog will bark.
cmoney
November 28 2007, 8:29PM
I too am wondering why he only shot one of them. Did he run out of bullets? I would have emptied the chamber on those punks. They came to his home to do bodily harm and at least one of them got just what they deserved. If this were in Jena, La. and the mob had been Black boys at the home of a White family, they would have been shot dead and then charged with the theft of bullets from the White man that shot them. To me, this isn't even a racial issue, other than the fact that the punks were using the N word. Even if they hadn't been using racist language, their behavior warranted the response. Also, you ever notice how everyone named "White" is Black?
*M*
November 28 2007, 8:33PM
what I would do? Stay inside my house and call the police. For it to be self defense you have to use equal or less force, they did kill that boy.
The people should not have on their property, think before you act.
LaFontaye
November 28 2007, 9:03PM
Indeed I have, and vice versa.
diamante
November 28 2007, 9:39PM
If five teen would have came to my house in two cars with bats going after my son whether they were black , white, hispanic, asian, etc, there would have been chalk outlines for each of them where they were standing. This has nothing to do with race. This man has a right to protect his family. What if those boys would have broke his windows out of his house or something with those bats? I'm sorry that someone had to lose their life in this situation, but just think, if the boys would have stayed at the party and not follow the boy home, he would still be alive today. We always want to blame the person that pulled the trigger, but we never look at the victims actions.
Byron
November 28 2007, 10:26PM
In response to: "Let four black men run up on the police with bats and see what happens." If the police opened fire & killed them, we would be screaming that the police used excessive force. Baisden would be organizing a march for justice if those officers were not arrested. Mr. White understandably wanted to protect his son. The gun that "accidentally" fired in the face of a 17 year old boy was not accidentally loaded, & it wasn't an accident that Mr. White stepped outside with the gun in his hand. I would do whatever it takes to protect my family. In doing so, that doesn't absolve me of the consequences of my actions. A boy is dead. Everything else falls under "extenuating circumstances," & these factors were surely considered when the charges were reduced from murder to manslaughter.
MLee
November 29 2007, 1:08AM
Mr. White should have shot and killed all 5 boys and claimed self defense. That is what my father would have done under the same situation. The next lynch mob would think twice before putting themselves in equal danger. I am a loving person, but love has its limits.
Ron
November 29 2007, 8:08AM
Malcolm said if someone touches you, it is your duty to make sure that man (person) never touches you again (not the quote word for word). That 53 year old man was born in the 50's, and saw the turmoil thereafter then, and in the 60's and so on, so he knows what a truck full of angry white people with weapons are all about. It was wrong to shoot the child, He should of shot a warning shot in the air, but that wouldn't have stopped the white boys; like one of the boys being killed, from future harassment by the white community on the son, mother, and father if he's not found guilty. Thank God the black boy was able to get home before those kids caught up to him.
Equalnox
November 29 2007, 8:34AM
The only thing Mr. White should be charged with is carrying an unlicensed gun. Maybe he should have stayed inside and waited for the police, but when your testosterone is pumping, people get hurt. I do agree with Thirtydaes, Terrence, and Bingo that we can't forget the black on black crime that's killing our society more effectively than modern day white racism is. Let's acknowledge both sides of the street that are effecting our community. Like Jeff Hobbs said, I'd like to know what went on with the black boy and the white girl in that chat room. And where were the parents of these teen thugs when they were boozing it up at a party? Somebody needs to be charged with distributing alcohol to minors.
C. Baptiste-Williams
November 29 2007, 9:22AM
it amazes me how some of these comments show the little respect we have for someone's life. And how we think violence is the only answer to violence.
louis wright
November 29 2007, 9:54AM
No it amazes me how Black folks tend to value White life over Black life. These teenagers had WEAPONS! A bat is a WEAPON! It's not a toy. A bat can break bones, create brain damage, and kill. It's no different from a gun. I have no sympathy for this teenager because it's clear they lacked respect for authority or better yet Black people. This is not the first time I have heard a group of teenagers running up or in a person's home in the suburbs. When you charge onto another persons property with or without a weapon making threats you have walked into a danger zone. In this case, he created his on issue. If the situation was reverse, and a group of Black boys charged onto a White persons property under the same circumstances, I would say the same thing.
MidwestGuy
November 29 2007, 10:15AM
On a personal level, I do not believe White was justified in the slaying of the white boy.
He should've stayed inside of his home and called the police. If he were already outside his home when they arrived that would be a different story.
This sort of vigilante justice really needs to stop.
He should be convicted.
Shabaka
November 29 2007, 10:53AM
I find it chilling that most people agree that Mr White was justified in using his unregistered gun. He did kill the boy! With an illegal gun! If the police had been there before the tragic shooting, he woulda been charged for possessing that weapon. He knew all this prior to stepping outside the door. He's in his 50's for goodness' sakes! Like someone said, why didn't he shoot in the air? The kids woulda peed their pants and run off for damn sure! And he would have had to face another lesser charge than taking someone's life (thug or not). That's in my opinion a reasonable thing to do. He needs to be held accountable for his actions.
Alto
November 29 2007, 11:20AM
Wow...For all those who say he should be convicted for protecting his home..You have to keep in mind this man did not go out and seek harm..Those antagonist came to his home and lawn in multitudes and the young dude who got shot tried to GRAB THE GUN FOR HIMSELF TO SHOOT AT THEM. Self Defense is the name of the game..Even though Florida has its hand, fists, and pockets full of fuckery regarding its law THIS here shooting is backed by our law on gun control..If a person even says with intent and brandishing a weapon to threaten your life you can shoot them in defense down here.
Andy
November 29 2007, 12:58PM
Just curious for all of ya'll who say he was wrong, what if a mob tried to bust into your house? Would you just sit there and wait 5, 10, 15 minutes if you are lucky for the police? The laws in this country have always been behind the homeowner when his safety is threatened with an intruder, and, they should remain that way.
These young thugs, of any race need to be put in their places by people who will not cower down in fear. Its fear of hoodlums that has so many neighborhoods out of control with crime. Stand up to them.
Derrick from Philly
November 29 2007, 1:08PM
Those of you who keep saying, "this is not a racial issue", where do y'all live? Canada?
Any incident which involves Black people and White people in the United States is a racial incident whether the participants realize it or not.
I'm about as liberal as a Black ma..."queen" can get regarding race relations, but I aint no historically unaware fool. I'm not going to disregard 400 years of history when looking at the the status of race relations in this country in 2008. Our, I repeat, OUR whole history as a nation is interwoven with the effort (maybe successful effort) to maintain white supremacy in OUR country. It aint pretty but it's true.
As distant from Black America as Dumb OJ is, his 1st trial was so racial that many Black folks who knew he was guilty still supported his acquittal because of the horrible race relations between police and Blacks. His upcoming trial? Who cares? He aint even pretty no more.
J
November 29 2007, 1:16PM
Some of you will be sitting right next to the brilliant Mr. White in a deluxe government suite if you go through life with that attitude.
If ol pappy White had handled this like a man all of those baby guido Myspace whores would probably be spending Xmas in some boot camp or detention center. It would have been fairly easy to get them to hang themselves and murder them in court.
Now his wife has to raise and support their child alone and that boy canNOT stay in that area. I don't even know why any black folk are over there anyway. People talk about the south, but guidoville hasn't changed either.
JW
November 29 2007, 1:47PM
As Chris Rock said "...it ain't right but I understand...". I'm sorry a person had to lose their life over this but you cannot go to someone's house looking for a fight and not expect to be in danger yourself. The father could have very well waited for the police, but let's be honest, Blacks on the whole do not have a lot of faith in the police in this country. Would you sit idly by while your property is being destroyed by a mob of drunk teenagers and hope that the police get their in time enough to prevent you from being killed or seriously hurt? Get Real! The survival instinct will kick in sooner (not later), and you will defend you and yours by any means necessary. I agree with the points made about how the NRA should be all behind this one, because it is a classic case of a person protecting their person and property. Although immoral, this may not be illegal.
brian
November 29 2007, 2:26PM
i ask everyone on this site, and you still don't think that we need a black president? trust and believe, miss thing hillary wouldn't do a damn thing to rectify race relations in this country. it's amazing that black people are so stupid for trusting a white person versus trusting someone in their own race to run this country. if i hear of another black community icon endorsing hillary i will scream. and you wonder why things aren't changing.peace.
MidwestGuy
November 29 2007, 2:32PM
Andy, unfortunately that was not the case here. The mob didn't bust down his door. There entered onto his property.
In most juridictions, you have to right to use violence if you are in immediate danger. White placed himself in that danger by walking outside.
I know that most people believe that you can shoot someone for standing in your driveway, but you can't, not in most states.
J, I'm not sure what constitutes him not being a "man" by shooting someone who came to his house with a bat.
Further, "myspace whores" doesn't seem like the appropriate word for a mob of guys coming to his house with a bat.
The Jena Six were called thugs
The Long Island 5 are called myspace whores.
Heaven help us.
jas
November 29 2007, 3:24PM
It was an accident; now let the man go!!
jonathan perry
November 29 2007, 4:45PM
the only crime he is guilty of is possession of an unregistered hand gun.
He is guilty of bringing a gun to a knife fight. Given, however, today's climate and brewing racial tensions that exists in this great land of the free and home of the phobic, his reaction is not only warranted but expected.
My experiences with racism haven't been pretty, but any reaction or response associated with an eminent threat
ones life should be understandable.
MY questions are:
- has White been a victim of this kind of racism in the past?
- if so, how did he handle it then?
- what role did the murder of his uncles play in his his decision to respond the way he did.
- if he were faced with this situation again, would he respond differently or the same
MLee
November 29 2007, 4:57PM
What was Mr. White suppose to do? Wait in his house for the mob to break in and drag his son out? I have no doubt if he did not have that unregistered gun, he and his son would both be dead. You may look at those White boys as babies, but in a pack they are very unpredictable and dangerous as hell. Now add alcohol to the mix. It is just history repeating itself, and you already know the outcome if Mr. White had not responded in the way he did. I value human life, but everything is out the window when my life or a loved ones life is in danger.
J
November 29 2007, 11:31PM
Some of you act like it was the end of f-cking Thriller with dozens of those greaseballs coming into the house through every opening. A five year old girl could beat their asses.
If they would have called the cops or just ignored them the idiots would have broke something, and left to go home and frost their hair and take more pouty mirror shots for their Myspace.
White's actions cannot be defended. If people put bullets in every idiot that snacked on tough guy cookies and puffed out their chest, we'd all be locked up or dead. That's why we have cops, so we don't have to be dicks.
loi wade
November 30 2007, 1:37AM
Here we go with this shit again. Black boys ain't gon' evah learn! Every white face is an enemy until they prove otherwise. And the father. He not only jumped the gun(no pun intended) but he pulled an illegal piece on a bunch of white kids. He wanted to get locked up. Now his wife and children are left alone and are vulnerable to attacks by all kinds of Nazi organizations. Who, no doubt, will feel it is their 'duty' to avenge their white brothers death.
If I were in that situation, I would have called the police and said there are a bunch of white kids on my property with a bat. I do have the legal right to hurt them don't I? They would have been there before I hung up. If this isn't a wake up call to black men that white women still yell 'rape', I don't know what is. Those kids had some nerve. The only good thing about this is that next time they will think twice about trying to bully someone.
Chris
November 30 2007, 4:37AM
Well lets put it like this. If this Man is going to be prosecuted. Then that White Man in Texas who killed those 2 Mex-Amer guys who was robbing another property and not his and was no where near his property. Then his ASS should be prosecuted as well. Just treat everyone according to the laws NOT BY RACE according to the laws!
lovejones
November 30 2007, 4:59AM
In this country, no matter where ya live, no matter how much ya got in your bank account, or how famous you are, white is always right, and black is always wrong in the eyes of this nation. I just don't get it, when are we gonna realize that we can never get away with what the white folk do, I don't care how justified we are in our actions, they are gonna find something to hang you on, and don't you ever forget it. I live down south, and I mean this type of attitude is openly displayed, although some of us try to close our eyes and pretend that it doesn't. I'm not racial, but facts are just facts, and I won't ignore them. I agree with whomever said that we are yet too silent, with all the blacks that have some influence in our nation, it just saddens me, how it took Jena 6 to get us out, this goes on every day. But those same folks who marched for Jeana 6, wouldn't budge if it was about black sgl rights. So we can't expect them, to treat us better than we treat ourselves. Be BLessed My Bruthas.
Derrick from Philly
November 30 2007, 10:35AM
Loi, MidwestGuy & J,
I understand the logic of what y'all are saying: Mr White and his family are in a terrible position now, and also, a life has been lost--but I can understand why he reacted the way he did.
I've been in similar situations, and the regrets are just as powerful if you don't use extreme force (if you got any). You may regret it the rest of your "do the right thing" life.
Five vicious, foamin' at the mouth thugs with baseball bats?...bats aimed at me? Child, if I didn't shoot, I'd wished I had after them damn surgeons try to reconstruct my face and head. Gay people don't like no baseball bats coming at our faces. Shiiiit.
loi wade
November 30 2007, 10:56AM
Keith, I know this has nothing to do with this story,but it does have to do with blatant homophobia and racism. You should print an article on the fools protesting your mans movie 'Dirty Laundry'. I clicked on the link in the sidebar and read the comments. They not only attack gays but blacks as well. And they don't try and cover it up. Well I let them have it with plenty of bible quotes to back me up. Do you know they erased ALL of my comments. They did NOT want to hear it. And believe me, I adhered to all of their rules. They are so stupid they said Jennifer Lewis was a gay rights activist who played Effie in Dreamgirls! The idiots don't know the difference between Lewis, Holliday and Hudson. Please blog on this and everyone needs to click on that link in the side bar.
LaFontaye
November 30 2007, 1:07PM
I agree loi wade; Mr. Boykin should blog about the type of tomfoolery that's going on regarding these religious morons in protest of Dirty Laundry; i.e., 'A right-wing so-called Christian group is threatening to protest the movie because it depicts black gay people in a positive light.'
!!! I mean the right-wing bully pulpit is a complete laughable joke.
loi wade
November 30 2007, 2:12PM
That last name comment made by cmoney and LaFontaye is just so hilarious because my daughters father is a White. Her last name is a combo of mine and my ex-girlfriends for the record(LOL). Thanks for the humor. It was so needed.
charles
November 30 2007, 3:20PM
I'm a straight white man, came across this after reading the story and googling.
My take? I have a lot of sympathy for Mr. White. Too bad the kid died, but he shouldn't have been threatening someone in front of his own house. I've got a lot of trouble thinking a crime was committed here. Yeah, Mr. white should have waited on the front porch and let them come to him - would have certainly looked better in court. And he should have called the cops.
But fundamentally, they came to HIS house.
No need to put it in Black/White terms. Yeah, racists exist. But I'm pretty sure that if you polled white people in this country, most would be at least moderately supportive of Mr. White. What the grand jury came out with is evidence of that.
loi wade
November 30 2007, 3:22PM
I wanted you guys to know this was my latest post they erased on that sudo Christian blog:"When you come for Derrick you come for me. That's MY 'Family'. When it comes to slavery, whites always want to pull that handful of decent human beings out of their behinds. They don't want to face the truth. It was in the name of christianity that they did all the unGodly things they did. Call themselves trying to save decent people. And why? Because they didn't live their lives the way white people felt thd. Now, you tell me what has changed. NOTHING. The same old fake christians spouting the same old hate".That was in response to something some fool had to say to Derrickfromphilly just because of his opinion.
Derrick from Philly
November 30 2007, 3:57PM
Thanks, Loi. You know, I didn't even go back to the site after I posted. They were attacking Nathan Hale's film for ridiculous reasons. I think you and I were trying to achieve the same goal: to show those Christian fanatics that hyporcrisy may be the greatest legacy American "Christians" have accomplished--with the slaughter of the Native Americans, and the building of this country with the blood of Africans/African Americans.
That was my first time on a right-wing Christian blog. They're lunatics...well, so am I, but I don't bother nobody.
Thanks, again
loi wade
November 30 2007, 4:29PM
Derrick, People should be able to disagree and move on like we do on this site. They don't see it that way. If you don't believe like they 'tell' you to, they don't want to hear it. Did you see how the owner of the site argues with his posters? Keith would never do anything that damn dumb. I'm just glad they are showing their true colors.
Randy
November 30 2007, 6:26PM
When someone comes at you in a group with a baseball bat it is to do violence and to be charged while protecting yourself is just plain wrong. The death is a sad fact that violent behavior begets violent solutions. That drunken bravado, like grabbing for a gun, is always a bad idea. Mr. White is not guilty because some drunken teen grabbed for a gun and it accidently discharged.
I may not have had a gun to protect myself with. But
if I had one I would have used it when I was attacked by a mob with a baseball bat, and if they tried to grab for it I would imagine a similiar outcome. I believe Mr. White is charged because he isn't "white enough" and shame on the courts for being no better than a lynch mob themselves in that regard. The man should be released and all charges dropped, let the mob of white teens pay for the cost already acrued by the state in this matter.
UIB
December 1 2007, 5:18AM
an indirect case of a white girl screaming rape by a black man. She went to the white boys, they reacted, and went after him. But...what has changed is that Black people have stop running, and are confronting these beast that show up in their face.
Mr. White defended himself, clear and simple. You do not roll up in anyone's home with the 'intent' to do harm, and not expect to receive it.
Who's responsible; the white girl who started the whole thing. Her bigotry (even though the young man left), lit the fire. That wasn't good enough, she wanted the young bloods, blood, sacrafice. She will have to live with the death of her buddy, not Mr. White. She should be up in court facing charges.
ChicagoChild
December 1 2007, 10:29AM
Why is there always some White female behind every catalyst of race crime against Black males?
When will Black men learn not to mess with or even to talk to or befriend these ditzy and dishonorable broads?
Just like Black men know the deadly psychological make-up of the White man; you had better understand that the same twisted demon is in the White woman.
Ask any a Black woman. She has to do battle with BOTH.
loi wade
December 1 2007, 12:17PM
ChicagoChild, are we the only ones that see this? She gave birth to his ass didn't she? And have you ever noticed, that there is always something wrong with brothers that chase others? If you take the time to have a conversastion with one, you will see exactly what I am talking about. They are not right upstairs. I don't see why black women get so upset or my babies (black gay men. yes I am a serious fag hag LOL!) either for that matter. They ain't loosing out on shit. I wouldn't want that headache.
As for black women doing battle with white women, I relish the challenge. Of course, that is the last thing it is, because I always win. I am too well armed. Can't you tell? It takes a lot to shut me up. I don't give a damn. That is why I use my real name.
loi wade
December 1 2007, 12:49PM
And,UIB, you are also right. I hope his lawyer has the sense enough to bring up those very points. You might be kidding about bringing charges against the white girl, but in actuality they should. She should be charged with inciting a riot that resulted in a death. Had it not been for her unwarranted actions(the boy left the party) her friend would still be alive.
QTMIA
December 1 2007, 2:32PM
MR. WHITE DID THE RIGHT THING ...I WOULD HAVE F_UCKED EVERY LAST ONE OF THOSE WHITE BASTARDS UP...
UIB
December 1 2007, 4:16PM
loi wade thanks, and I am serious about charges being brought up on the white girl. This experience should haunt and plague her for life. The whole incident started with her! -clear and simple. Why didn't she go to her parents, and not to a bunch of hyped-up 'intoxicated' teenage boys. Was the Black young man invited to the party?
She lied, just like this white woman (some time ago) accused this Black man of murdering her children. She got up on national television and swore her children was murdered by a Black man, and he raped her. Later, come to find out; she murdered her own children. But because she was white, America believed her story first.
This time (and thanks in part to strong Black women like you) the Black family stood-up, and (no-pun) shut the white boy up. But the white girl (I'm sure) is being embraced like she is the victim.
jas
December 2 2007, 3:43AM
white black white black white black white black... it goes on and on doesnt it. this is getting so old by now.
loi wade
December 2 2007, 11:53AM
'Old' things usually die. I don't see that happening with the 'white/black' problem. Racism in America seems to have discovered the fountain of youth. One thing we do agree with is that it goes on and on. And, as long as it does, so will I.
Ronluv
December 6 2007, 9:57AM
Its really sad! One thing about it weather white or black a parent, a homeowner, a man will do what ever it takes to9 protect. When i was a child i had problems with young black kids (i'm black too) my dad came to the door with a gun and scared the kids away. The problem is young people don't scare the same anymore they don't respect, not even there parents so what are we to do. One thing is go back to praying for direction. My prayers are with all involed in this situation. All jury, judge, pros. ect....
Denise
December 15 2007, 12:46AM
It amazes me who this whole thing has become racial, a 17 year old boy was shot to death. My parents never fought my battles for me, and maybe if this man did the same a child would not have died that night. It is unfortunate that these boys showed up looking for a fight, and it is foolish on all involved that they were intoxicated and driving cars, and yes these boys were hot-headed, but that were boys not thinking clearly, they were invinicible due to alcohol consumption. I think everyone has to stop playing the race card every time there is an issue between whites and black. This is just ridiculous
Peter
December 23 2007, 10:54PM
I can't believe he got convicted of anything at all. Who were his lawyers??
If someone shows up on my lawn after already terrorizing my son, forcing me out of my bed and having to grab my handgun to defend my life and my family at 11.30 pm at night, threatening me, calling me names, and it's a bunch of hoods with a baseball bat acting drunk and racist and aggressive - I WILL SHOOT THEM IN THE FACE. I WILL SHOOT THEM ALL IN THE FACE. I WON'T STOP FIRING UNTIL I'M OUT OF AMMO. AND THEN I'LL GO TO THE GARAGE AND MAKE SURE EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM IS GOOD AND DEAD SO THEY NEVER TERRORIZE ME OR MY FAMILY AGAIN. DICK CHENEY WOULD HAVE NOTHING ON ME AFTER I GOT DONE WITH THESE TERRORISTS.
how in the world did he get convicted?
MLee
December 24 2007, 6:06PM
Peter, the guilty verdict really did not surprise me, considering the racial mix of that area. As I said in previous postings, if I was in the same situation as Mr. White all 5 boys would be dead, knowing beforehand that I may have to pay a heavy price. One thing Mr. White’s lawyers did wrong was claiming the shooting was an accident. The case should have been presented as self defense. He would have had a better chance even though it still may not have been enough for that jury. Did you see on the news yesterday the family and friends in the court room after the verdict of the boy who died? Many of them looked like skin heads. Mr. White’s son didn’t even send the email that the white girl accused him of sending that set off the whole mess.
Comment Preview